Zuma lawyer plays 'spy tapes' trump card

Posted in categories

  • CyberREPORTs

See also

Publish date 21 May 2019
Issue Number 1782
Diary Legalbrief eLaw
‘There is no case against me and there never will be. They failed for 15 years to charge me and they can’t. It’s clear this is politically motivated’. With these words, former President Jacob Zuma offered his take on the ...

‘There is no case against me and there never will be. They failed for 15 years to charge me and they can’t. It’s clear this is politically motivated’. With these words, former President Jacob Zuma offered his take on the first day of proceedings at the KZN High Court (Pietermaritzburg) in his application to secure a permanent stay of prosecution on a host of corruption charges he claims he always wanted to deal with, yet spent years trying to avoid, notes Legalbrief. Earlier, Zuma's legal team played what it believes is its trump card: an exceptional and extraordinary circumstance created by the NPA. Acknowledging that the delay in bringing Zuma to court was not enough in itself to secure a permanent stay of prosecution, his lawyer, Advocate Muzi Sikhakhane, explained that an extraordinary circumstance, which has to be taken into account, did in fact exist.

 

The Zuma trump card is the so-called ‘spy tapes’, the recordings of phone conversations between then NDPP Bulelani Ngcuka and former Scorpions boss Leonard McCarthy discussing the timing for prosecuting Zuma in order to boost the chances of Thabo Mbeki winning re-election. ‘If you find that it's not unlawful ... to do what we say Leonard McCarthy and Bulelani Ngcuka did (and) is not against the spirit and provisions of our Constitution, I must lose this case,’ said Sikhakhane, according to the TimesLIVE report. ‘If you find that the NPA, from today and going forward, in pursuit of someone who's accused ... can do what Leonard McCarthy was doing – they can take instructions from the DA and the ANC and everybody in order to time things to suit political players – you are free to take that decision. I must lose this case, if this court does not find that violation extraordinary.’ Zuma faces 16 charges, including fraud‚ corruption and racketeering. These relate to 783 payments he allegedly received as a bribe to protect French arms manufacturer Thales from an investigation into the controversial multibillion-rand arms deal.